Can Introverts Succeed as Embedded Librarians?


This question came up twice at the LIANZA conference last week: once in my workshop and once in the Q&A following my keynote. The interest may have been triggered in part by a comment Stephen Abram made in his earlier address to the conference: that 70% of librarians are introverts while 70% of the general population are extroverts. Stephen made it clear that he wasn’t saying librarians couldn’t relate — just that it was an issue many of us have to deal with. Nonetheless, the idea was planted.

So, what’s my answer? My answer is Yes! — introverts absolutely can succeed as embedded librarians. Here are a few reasons why:

1. There are examples. A very successful embedded librarian I interviewed volunteered that she was an introvert, and added that “introverts can do this!” I also came up as an “I” in the Myers-Briggs system (though see below), and I like to think I had some success in my days as an embedded librarian. There are others I’ve met who are probably “I”s as well who are successful. So there are examples.

2. Introverts can form relationships. We often talk about the importance of establishing strong, trusting working relationships in embedded librarianship. The popular concept of an introvert seems to be a shy, asocial person who can’t form relationships. But as an HR professional and trained M-B facilitator explained it to me, the I/E dichotomy in Myers-Briggs typology is about where you draw energy from: I’s from within; E’s from others. I’s may operate differently, but they can have social and relationship building skills all the same.

3. There are I’s and then there are I’s. As I mentioned above, the first time I did the Myers-Briggs test, I came up as an I. However, a few years later I took it again and had a more thorough analysis of the results. The second time I came up as balanced between I and E. People are different mixes of I and E attributes on the Myers-Briggs, and the I label covers a broad range of variations.

So the bottom line is, if you’re an Introvert librarian, don’t let that label define, deter, or discourage you. You too can be successful as an embedded librarian.

P.S. Extroverts can be successful embedded librarians too!


4 Responses to “Can Introverts Succeed as Embedded Librarians?”

  1. nksinfo2 Says:

    As a strong Myers-Briggs “I” who enjoys interacting with customers almost as much as finding the information they need ;-), I’m definitely tickled by your post.

    While not officially an embedded *librarian* (having left the library to take a job of an information analyst within another department) I am an embedded information professional having the time of my life.

    Here’s to a great 2011 for all of us, I or E.

  2. Kelly Cieslak Says:

    I am heartened by this post. Thank you! I am a fairly strong I on the MB scale and, in fact, one of the careers recommended for the I personality is a librarian. So, off to library school I went (not for just that reason, but it certainly contributed to making the decision). Then I got to library school and started learning about how “out there” we have to be – whether that means with customer service in a traditional library setting or by being active in social networking communities. Despite being an I, I find those opportunities exciting. Ultimately it is about connecting people with information, and being an I doesn’t deter me from wanting to do that. Dave is right … being an I is about where you get your energy from. We I types may not be attending every single social event, but that doesn’t mean we can’t be excellent 21st century librarians.

  3. Networking for people who hate networking … | Marketing Matters for Librarians Says:

    […] […]

  4. A Learning Librarian Says:

    […] Shumaker, D. (2010, December, 9). Can introverts succeed as an embedded librarian? [Web log post]. Retrieved from […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: